Aortic valve disease is one of the major diseases threatening human health. Transcatheter aortic valve replacement (TAVR) is a new treatment for aortic disease. Preoperative evaluation is of great significance to the successful operation and the long-term quality of life of patients. The 3D printing technology can fully simulate the cardiac anatomy of patients, create personalized molds for patients, improve surgical efficiency, reduce surgical time and surgical trauma, and thus achieve better surgical results. In this review, the relevant literatures were searched, and the evaluation effect of 3D printing technology on the operation of TAVR was reviewed, so as to provide clinical reference.
ObjectiveTo evaluate the clinical value of three-dimensional (3D) printing model in accurate and minimally invasive treatment of double outlet right ventricle (DORV).MethodsFrom August 2018 to August 2019, 35 patients (22 males and 13 females) with DORV aged from 5 months to 17 years were included in the study. Their mean weight was 21.35±8.48 kg. Ten patients who received operations guided by 3D printing model were allocated to a 3D printing model group, and the other 25 patients who received operations without guidance by 3D printing model were allocated to a non-3D printing model group. Preoperative transthoracic echocardiography and CT angiography were performed to observe the location and diameter of ventricular septal defect (VSD), and to confirm the relationship between VSD and double arteries.ResultsThe McGoon index of patients in the 3D printing model group was 1.91±0.70. There was no statistical difference in the size of VSD (13.20±4.57 mm vs. 13.40±5.04 mm, t=−0.612, P=0.555), diameter of the ascending aorta (17.10±2.92 mm vs. 16.90±3.51 mm, t=0.514, P=0.619) or diameter of pulmonary trunk (12.50±5.23 mm vs. 12.90±4.63 mm, t=−1.246, P=0.244) between CT and 3D printing model measurements. The Pearson correlation coefficients were 0.982, 0.943 and 0.975, respectively. The operation time, endotracheal intubation time, ICU stay time and hospital stay time in the 3D printing model group were all shorter than those in the non-3D printing model group (P<0.05).ConclusionThe relationship between VSD and aorta and pulmonary artery can be observed from a 3D perspective by 3D printing technology, which can guide the preoperative surgical plans, assist physicians to make reasonable and effective decisions, shorten intraoperative exploration time and operation time, and decrease the surgery-related risks.
The incidence of valvular heart disease (VHD) increases with age, and its principal therapy is valve replacement. However, in recent years, the emergence of transcatheter interventions has changed the traditional therapy, making high-risk patients of surgery see dawn of hope. 3D printing technology has developed rapidly since it was applied to the medical field in 1990. Moreover, it has been widely applied in many surgical majors via refined reduction technology. However, the application of 3D printing technology in cardiovascular surgery is still in the preliminary stage, especially in the field of VHD. This article aims to review basic principles of 3D printing technology, its advantages in the therapy of VHD, and its current status of clinical application. Furthermore, this article elaborates current problems and looks forward to the future development direction.
According to the needs of CT image evaluation for transapical transcatheter aortic valve replacement (TAVR), 20 clinical questions were proposed by the Delphi method, 15 questions were initially determined, and 12 clinical questions were summarized and determined by domestic experts. PubMed, Web of Science, Wanfang, and CNKI databases were searched by computer to collect the relevant literature from inception to November 2022, and finally 53 studies were included. Based on evidence-based study and evaluation experience, 3 meetings were held to give recommendations for preoperative CT data acquisition method, preoperative imaging evaluation of aortic root, imaging evaluation of transapical approach, preoperative auxiliary guidance of TAVR by CT images combined with 3D printing, and postoperative imaging evaluation of transapical TAVR, hoping to promote the standardized and successful development of transapical TAVR in China.
3D printing technology has a promising prospect of medical use and clinical value, and may play an important role in the field of thoracic and cardiovascular surgery, such as preoperative diagnosis, surgical planning, surgical approach alternatives and organ replacement. This review focuses on the development of 3D printing technology in recent years and its use and prospect in the field of thoracic and cardiovascular surgery including surgical teaching and simulation, personalized prosthesis implantation, and artificial organ transplantation.
Objective To assess the application value of 3-dimensional(3D) printing technology in surgical treatment for congenital tracheal stenosis. Methods We retrospectively analyzed the clinical data of preoperative diagnosis, intra-operative decision-making and postoperative follow-up of four children with congenital tracheal stenosis under the guidance of 3D printing in our hospital between February 2013 and May 2014. There were 3 males and 1 female aged 23.0±7.1 months. Among them, two children were with pulmonary artery sling, one with ventricular septal defect, and the other one with tetralogy of Fallot. The airway stenosis was diagnosed preoperatively by chest CT scan and 3D printing tracheal models, and was confirmed by the help of bronchoscopy under anesthesia. During operation the associated cardiac malformation was corrected firstly under extracorporeal circulation followed by tracheal malformation remedy. The design and implementation of tracheal operation plans were guided by the shape and data from 3D printing trachea models. There were two patients with long segment of tracheal stenosis who received slide anastomosis. And the other two patients were characterized with tracheal bronchus, one of which combined ostial stenosis of right bronchial performed extensive slide anastomosis, and the other one performed end to end anastomosis. Results All the children’s preoperative 3D printing trachea models were in accord with bronchoscopy and intra-operative exploration results. Intra-operative bronchoscopy confirmed that all tracheal stenosis cured completely. All anastomotic stomas were of integrity, and all the luminals were fluent. There was no operative death or no serious complication. During 1-2 years follow-up, all patients breathed smoothly and their airways were of patency by postoperative 3D printing trachea model. Conclusion 3D printing can provide a good help to congenital tracheal stenosis in preoperative diagnosis, the design of operation plan, intra-operative decision-making and manipulation, which can improve the operation successful rate of tracheal stenosis.
Congenital tracheal stenosis (CTS) is a rare but potentially life-threatening disease which results in congnital airway lesion. CTS is often associated with cardiovascular anomalies and presented with a wide spectrum of symptoms. CTS has challenged pediatric surgeons for decades. Various classic approaches and new techniques, including computational fluid dynamics, tissue-engineering trachea, and 3D printing have been proposed for diagnosis and treatment of CTS. This review provides a snapshot of the main progress of diagnosis and treatment of CTS.
Objective To evaluate the effect of the 3D-printed heart model on congenital heart disease (CHD) education through systematic review and meta-analysis. Methods The literature about the application of the 3D-printed heart model in CHD education was systematically searched by computer from PubMed, Web of Science, and EMbase from inception to November 10, 2022. The two researchers independently screened the literature, extracted data and evaluated the quality of the literature. Cochrane literature evaluation standard was used to evaluate the quality of randomized controlled trials, and JBI evaluation scale was used for cross-sectional and cohort studies. ResultsAfter screening, 23 literatures were included, including 7 randomized controlled trials, 15 cross-sectional studies and 1 cohort study. Randomized controlled trials were all at low-risk, cross-sectional studies and and the cohort study had potential bias. There were 4 literatures comparing 3D printing heart model with 2D image teaching and the meta-analysis result showed that the effect of 3D printing heart model on theoretical achievement was more significant compared with 2D image teaching (SMD=0.31, 95%CI –0.28 to 0.91, P=0.05). Conclusion The application of the 3D-printed heart model in CHD education can be beneficial. But more randomized controlled trials are still needed to verify this result.
ObjectiveTo explore the feasibility of lumbar puncture models based on 3D printing technology for training junior orthopaedic surgeons to find the optimal pedicle screw insertion points.MethodsMimics software was used to design 3D models of lumbar spine with the optimal channels and alternative channels. Then, the printed lumbar spine models, plasticine, and cloth were used to build lumbar puncture models. From January 2018 to June 2019, 43 orthopedic trainees performed simulated operations to search for the insertion points of pedicle screws base on the models. The operations were performed once a day for 10 consecutive days, and the differences in operation scores and operation durations of the trainees among the 10 days were compared.ResultsAll the trainees completed the surgical training operations successfully, and there were significant differences in the operation scores (13.05±2.45, 14.02±3.96, 17.58±3.46, 21.02±2.04, 23.40±4.08, 25.14±3.72, 27.26±6.09, 33.37±4.23, 35.00±4.15, 38.49±1.70; F=340.604, P<0.001) and operation durations [(22.51±4.28), (19.93±4.28), (18.05±2.89), (17.05±1.76), (16.98±1.97), (15.47±1.74), (13.51±1.42), (12.60±2.17), (12.44±1.71), (11.91±1.87) minutes; F=102.359, P<0.001] among the 10 days.ConclusionThe 3D models of lumbar puncture are feasible and repeatable, which can contribute to surgical training.
Objective To evaluate the deviation between actual and simulated screw placement after cervical pedicle screw placement assisted by 3D printed navigation template, and analyze the correlation between screw placement deviation and navigation pipe length. Methods A total of 40 patients undergoing cervical 1-7 pedicle screw insertion assisted by 3D printed navigation template in Zigong Fourth People’s Hospital between February 2018 and August 2020 were included in this prospective study. These patients were divided into 3 groups randomly, including 12 patients with a 5-mm pipe length (5 mm group), 13 patients with a 10-mm pipe length (10 mm group), and 15 patients with a 15-mm pipe length (15 mm group). Three-dimensional modeling was performed on preoperative cervical CT images of these patients and simulated pedicle screw was placed. Individualized pedicle screw navigation templates were designed according to the position and direction of simulated pedicle screws, and 3D printing was performed on the cervical model and navigation templates. Preoperative 3D printed model and navigation templates were used to simulate the surgical process to confirm the safety of screws. During the operation, pedicle screw placement was performed according to the preoperative design and simulated surgical process. The postoperative CT images were registered with the preoperative CT images in 3D model. The safety of screw placement was evaluated by the postoperative screw placement Grade, and the accuracy of screw placement was evaluated by measuring the deviation of screw placement point and the deviation of screw placement direction in horizontal plane (inclination angle) and sagittal plane (head inclination angle). The influence of different navigation pipe lengths on the safety and accuracy of screw placement was analyzed. Results A total of 164 pedicle screws were inserted with navigation template assistance, including 48 screws (38 in Grade 0 and 10 in Grade 1) in the 5 mm group, 52 screws in the 10 mm group (all in Grade 0), and 64 screws (52 in Grade 0 and 12 in Grade 1) in the 15 mm group, and the difference in the grade among the three groups was statistically significant (P<0.05). When the navigation pipe length was 5, 10, and 15 mm, respectively, the screw entry point deviation was (1.87±0.63), (1.44±0.63), and (1.66±0.54) mm, respectively, the inclination angle deviation was (2.72±0.25), (0.90±0.21), and (1.84±0.35)°, respectively, and the head inclination angle deviation was (8.63±1.83), (7.15±1.38), and (8.24±1.52)°, respectively. The deviations in the 10 mm group were all significantly less than those in the other two groups (P<0.05). Conclusions In the cervical pedicle screw placement assisted by navigation template, all the screws were Grade 0 or Grade 1, with high safety. The mean deviation of the screw entry point is within 2 mm, with high accuracy. When the length of navigation pipe is 10 mm, the safety and accuracy of screw placement can be fully guaranteed.